I grew up
in the NHS, even before I left school I tested out my future career by
volunteering. I was smitten from the start. That sense of community, of working
for a common good and being able to make a difference some times in a small
way, sometimes in a huge way. Yes it's tiring usually, stressful often, the
shift-work a pain but the satisfaction a balancing point usually. But I wonder
if things are balanced now?
Levels of
stress, of workload, of pressure from targets and- in England at least- endless
reorganisation that has no apparent value or indeed common sense at its root,
are taking their toll.
The
workforce is struggling that much is evident. What is amazing in a way is how
much great work is done nonetheless; day in, day out. The evidence of cost
effectiveness of a national health service is plentiful, we know it’s not perfect but it’s nonetheless impressive. It’s part of our psyche, part of what we are proud of as a
nation; be that UK or Scotland.
As
regular readers of my blog know I have had many opportunities to be grateful
for the work of the NHS and indeed to challenge it to be as good as it can be.
I have twice had treatment for cancer and I haven't had to "break
bad" to pay for it. Haven't had to see myself be financially crippled
through bills (unlike my peers in the US in particular) to protect my long-term
health. Of course I have had many other impacts and some of them financial but
it’s not from paying for
healthcare. I also know I would stand at the barricades to defend the NHS and
its principle of free at the point of need.
But I
look at the situation in England and see the integration of healthcare being
fragmented, see private companies in the business of profit moving in to
improve a service we are told and I see a situation when the tax payer funded
sector is starting to fund private healthcare sector who are accountable to
shareholders and not those who pay for it and I wonder where will this end? As
it slowly shifts to private sector delivery, what is the logical next step in
England?
I notice
in myself a tendency to cross my fingers that this could never happen in
Scotland. Health after all is devolved. And we have given commitment in
Scotland to staying with a model of collaboration, of integration, of ensuring
the voice of lived experience helps to shape not only the person-centred one to
one care but also the service improvement. I applaud this and like to think I ,
along with many others have helped to influence this. And we see the positive impact
of investing in self-management, of the reality of how involving people truly
shapes policy and practice in a person-centred way, unencumbered by
reorganisation, that is at best a distraction, at worst decimates a service
that was previously successful.
How
fragile is this approach however although it currently has collective support,
a policy we sign up to and are still admittedly finding our way with. But as
policy elsewhere in the UK shifts and changes how much does that create a
tension that is unsustainable? How much does that shifting budget, between
public and private, impact on how Scotland's budget is allocated over time? The
budget then becoming the driver of a policy we don't want?
The
political discussion around the referendum in Scotland has only recently
shifted to focus on the NHS. And at first I was probably guilty of complacency.
The policy here is so different, cross party consensus in health is fairly
solid in most part but as I have looked at the question of divergence and
budgets, my concern has grown.
I heard
it said recently that so many in Scotland are "aff their sofas" and
engaged in this vital constitutional debate. What I would urge us all across
the UK to do is get "aff" our collective sofas and join in the battle
for our NHS. Let's not be guilty of only realising what we had after we have lost
it. But equally we shouldn't worship at its temple, more importantly we need to
help it evolve, improve and be truly responsive in partnership with those it
serves. Maybe we all need to be willing to properly invest in it too. And
finally to ensure that those who govern are properly accountable to us for our
health service and not impose policy that we didn't vote for and don't want;
whatever our nation is now and in the future.
Reasons
to be cheerful: the sun is shining and I have worked with some super people
this past few weeks. Not least in my first experience as a speaker for Women
for Independence. I loved the engagement of the audience and the passion of
those with a vision for a more socially equal and just society. It's inspiring
to be part of this movement for change.
No comments:
Post a Comment